
A couple of weekends ago, the Boyfriend and I dined at Fleur de Lys in San Francisco. I had been wanting to go there for some time, but for some reason, we just never made it.
But after watching Chef Hubert Keller on Top Chef and then watching him almost win Top Chef Masters last year, we finally put it at the top of our must-dine list. Four courses, a couple hundred dollars, and one cute French man later, I’m happy to say that we can now cross Fleur de Lys off our list.
Walking into the restaurant off Sutter and Taylor streets (by the way, we drive by all the time and NEVER realized it was there!), it seemed a bit crowded and overwhelming with three hostesses and a tiny bar where a couple more folks were standing around.
Thankfully we were promptly whisked away to our table in the corner where it was much more quaint. Although I sometimes like to people watch at restaurants, tonight we just wanted a quiet evening and our spot by the wall was perfectly cozy.
At Fleur de Lys, you can choose from 3, 4, or 5 courses – appetizer, seafood, meat, dessert, and cheese – choosing anything you want off the menu. This makes it much nicer than a traditional prix fixe where you can only choose from a select few.

We opted for the 4-course menu. As we waited for our appetizers, we were presented with an amuse bouche – a cauliflower salad with pine nuts in the spoon and a pumpkin curry soup in the cup.
I wasn’t a complete fan of the soup but the cauliflower salad was such a bright spoonful, it got me really excited for the rest of the meal!

Next came appetizers – I had the chilled dungeness crab salad accompanied by a lobster cream with caviar in the spoon and beets over goat cheese at the top of the plate. When this came out, it was so beautiful, like art on a plate, I almost didn’t want to eat it. But I did, and it was soooo good!

The Boyfriend had what was listed on the menu as a salmon souffle. I thought it was going to be an actual souffle in a ramekin. Instead it was a whole piece of salmon – still delicious nonetheless. But wouldn’t it have been cool if it was a souffle?

Next came the seafood courses. I ordered a salmon dish for the first time ever! My piece of salmon was potato and parmesan encrusted over a bed of broccolini and came with a porcini flan (rich but not as flavorful as I thought it would be). Overall, a yummy dish that’s definitely changed my mind about ordering salmon in the future.

The boyfriend had the hawaiian swordfish with a side of saffron soup. The dish looked amazing, and the flavors were good for the most part. But alas, his piece of fish was a little overdone.

I also usually don’t order filet mignon at restaurants either – I’m a ribeye kinda gal. But anything that comes with lobster and mac and cheese, I’m all for!
I have to say, this dish wasn’t the complete package for me. While my perfectly cooked, perfectly tender, and perfectly flavorful piece of filet was probably the best I’d ever had, the mac and cheese was a total flop. Not creamy at all, and reminded me of a flatter version of Kraft’s mac and cheese in a box – sorry Chef Hubert!!

For the Boyfriend’s meat course, he went with the suggestion of the server – the venison chop with chorizo. This wasn’t his favorite dish. To me, it tasted fine but totally lackluster and the chorizo didn’t seem to fit. The plating was a little old school, too, with the orange puree that looked like a carrot.

Finally dessert. Again at the suggestion of the server I choose the golden apple tart with a chocolate creme brulee. I don’t usually indulge in desserts so I look forward to eating out because that’s the only time I give myself a sweet treat. The chocolate creme brulee was sweet indeed, but the tart was far from a treat.
My idea of an apple tart is warm with a soft crust that just melts in your mouth. This tart crust was dry, almost like a shortbread cookie, and the filling tasted of apple, but on the plain side – where’s the cinnamon?

On the other hand, the boyfriend’s dessert was playful and really fun to eat. The FleurBurger is a sweet play on Chef Keller’s signature burgers!
The brioche bun features a fudge patty and the lettuce and tomatoes are actually slices of kiwi and… another fruit that I can’t recall. The “burger” is accompanied by a banana milkshake and pieces of fennel ice cream as french fries! I couldn’t taste the fennel, but the ice cream is nice with the rich burger. The Boyfriend is a complete fan of banana milkshakes and enjoyed this one very much!

Overall, I wouldn’t say that the meal was a home run. It started out strong with a few misses here and there. I might say that I’d visit again, but only to hopefully run into Chef Hubert Keller again outside of his restaurant as we were leaving.
He was very sweet, shaking our hands and asking us if we enjoyed our meal. He also graciously agreed to a photo with us, even after I confessed to him that I was a groupie – ha! The truth is, we love watching him on TV and wouldn’t mind visiting another one of his restaurants again in the future.
Have you dined at Fleur de Lys in San Francisco or Las Vegas? He’s also got the Burger Bar that I think we’ll try next time! Hope to see you there Chef Hubert!!
Enjoy this post? Subscribe to The Daily Cookie RSS feed and email to see where else I’m eating at these days in San Francisco.